Daily Development for October 3, 2005
by: Patrick A. Randolph, Jr.
Elmer F. Pierson Professor of Law
UMKC School of Law
Of Counsel: Blackwell Sanders Peper Martin
Kansas City, Missouri
LANDLORD/TENANT; NOTICE: Where tenant has right to claim abatement of rent upon “immediate” notice to landlord of injury to premises affecting tenant’s occupancy, tenant’s obligation to provide notice is not governed by general provision requiring that all notices from tenant by landlord be by certified or registered mail.
Ring v. Arts International, Inc., 7 Misc. 3d 869, 792 N.Y.S. 2d 296 (N.Y. Civ. Ct. 2004)
Tenant claimed that it was entitled to abate rent when the sprinkler system in its premises malfunctioned, dousing the area. The lease stated that if the premises were damaged by “fire or other casualty” tenant was to give landlord “immediate” notice. Then, the same provision in the lease stated that if the premises were rendered wholly unusable, then rent completely abated until Landlord effected a repair of the condition. When the sprinkler damage occurred, Tenant sent to Landlord a letter by regular mail stating that the premises had been rendered untenantable and that it was withholding rent.
Landlord disputed that the premises were rendered untenantable. When Tenant failed to pay rent, Landlord sued for possession, and Tenant defended on the grounds of the abatement right set forth in the lease.
One of the issues in the case was whether Tenant had properly invoked the right by mailing notice to the Landlord. Another part of the lease stated that “Except as otherwise in this lease provided. . . Any notice by Tenant to Owner must be by registered or certified mail . . . .” It was conceded that Tenant had not sent the notice by registered or certified mail.
The court first noted that the Landlord admitted that it had received the letter. It stated that the law was clear that where Landlord responds to a notice, demonstrating that it has received the notice, its failure to object promptly to the form of notice is a waiever of its right to assert tha tthe notice was invalid.
But the court’s second holding on the point is important to note. It held that the lease paragraph providing for casualty, by providing for “immediate notice” demonstrated that the parties did not intend that the “certified or registered” mail requirement apply. The court noted that the notice provision stated expressly that it these requirements applied “except as otherwise in this lease provided,” and in this case the lease did provide otherwise.
Comment 1: The editor views that court’s analysis of the notice requirement as not logical, although he cannot quarrel with the outcome as applied to these facts. Why should the requirement for “immediate notice” preclude use of registered or certified mail? Registered or certified mail might provide greater certainty of notice. Isn’t the landlord entitled to that? What if the tenant’s mailed notice had not reached the landlord at all. Was it nevertheless valid when mailed “immediately?”
Comment 2: Obviously there’s a drafting lesson here that might have more teeth in it in other circumstances. You can’t rely upon a general statement of notice requirements if arguably there is detail about the form of notice elsewhere in the lease. Either refer over or cover all notices of any kind in a single provision.
Items reported here and in the ABA publications
are for general information purposes only and
should not be relied upon in the course of
representation or in the forming of decisions in
legal matters. The same is true of all
commentary provided by contributors to the DIRT
list. Accuracy of data and opinions expressed
are the sole responsibility of the DIRT editor
and are in no sense the publication of the ABA.
Parties posting messages to DIRT are posting to
source that is readily accessible by members of
the general public, and should take that fact
into account in evaluating confidentiality
DIRT is an internet discussion group for serious
real estate professionals. Message volume varies,
but commonly runs 5 15 messages per work day.
Daily Developments are posted every work day.
subscribe, send the message
subscribe Dirt [your name]
To cancel your subscription, send the message
signoff DIRT to the address:
for information on other commands, send the
Help to the listserv address.
DIRT has an alternate, more extensive coverage that includes
commercial and general real estate matters but also focuses specifically upon
residential real estate matters. Because real estate brokers generally find
this service more valuable, it is named “BrokerDIRT.” But residential
specialist attorneys, title insurers, lenders and others interested in the
residential market will want to subscribe to this alternative list. If you
subscribe to BrokerDIRT, it is not necessary also to subscribe to DIRT, as
BrokerDIRT carries all DIRT traffic in addition to the residential discussions.
To subscribe to BrokerDIRT, send the message
subscribe BrokerDIRT [your name]
To cancel your subscription to BrokerDIRT, send the
signoff BrokerDIRT to the address:
DIRT is a service of the American Bar
Section on Real Property, Probate & Trust Law and
the University of Missouri, Kansas City, School
of Law. Daily Developments are copyrighted by
Patrick A. Randolph, Jr., Professor of Law, UMKC
School of Law, but Professor Randolph grants
permission for copying or distribution of Daily
Developments for educational purposes, including
professional continuing education, provided that
no charge is imposed for such distribution and
that appropriate credit is given to Professor
Randolph, DIRT, and its sponsors.
DIRT has a WebPage at:
Your e-mail address will only be used within the ABA and its entities. We do not sell or rent e-mail addresses to anyone outside the ABA.
To change your e-mail address or remove your name from any future general distribution e-mails you can call us at 1-800-285-2221, or write to: American Bar Association, Service Center, 321 N Clark Street, Floor 16, Chicago, IL 60610
If you are an ABA member, log in to the ABA Web site at https://e2k.exchange.umkc.edu/exchweb/bin/redir.asp?URL=http://www.abanet.org/abanet/common/MyABA/home.cfm to edit your member profile. Otherwise, complete the form located at https://e2k.exchange.umkc.edu/exchweb/bin/redir.asp?URL=https://www.abanet.org/members/join/coa2.html
To review our privacy statement, go to https://e2k.exchange.umkc.edu/exchweb/bin/redir.asp?URL=http://www.abanet.org/privacy_statement.html.
If you have any problems, please contact the list owner