Held: Counterclaim dismissed. There is no implied warranty of habitability encompassed within the concept of merchantable title, except (in Indiana) in a vendor/builder relationship. The Seventh Circuit court pointed out that every court addressing this issue has refused to expand the merchantable/marketable title doctrine to make the presence of hazardous waste an encumbrance of title.
Comment: Let us assume for the moment that the environmental conditions in question would give rise to a government right to enter the property, clean it up, and assess a lien for the damages. These government rights certainly interfere with the clear title to the property. They might be analogous, for example, to implied easement, constructive trust or equitable lien rights that third parties might have in the property, arising from conduct of a landowner prior to transfer. Thus, there is some logic to the transferee's position.
Another way to look at the environmental problems, however, is that they are simply conditions on the property subject to government regulation, and that even if the government regulation eventually might lead to the imposition of easement rights or lien rights, the existence of the condition is not the same as the existence of the rights. Therefore, although the conditions might be objectionable, they are not "title defects." This view of the situation, of course, is strengthened by the fact that most environmental laws only create rights in the government where the landowner refuses the option to conduct the clean-up privately.
The buyer's sole source of authority was a student law review piece: "Toxic Clouds on Titles, 19 B.C. Envtl. Aff. L. Rev. 355 (1992) Fortunately for the stability of real estate law, not every bright idea that a student publishes changes the world.
Items in the Daily Development section generally are extracted from the Quarterly Report on Developments in Real Estate Law, published by the ABA Section on Real Property, Probate & Trust Law. Subscriptions to the Quarterly Report are available to Section members only. The cost is nominal. For the last five years, these Reports annually have been collated, updated, indexed and bound into the Annual Survey of Developments in Real Estate Law, volumes 1-5, published by the ABA Press. The Annual Survey volumes are available for sale to the public. Contact Shawn Kaminsky at the ABA. (312) 988 5260.
Items reported here and in the ABA publications are for general information purposes only and should not be relied upon in the course of representation or in the forming of decisions in legal matters. Accuracy of data and opinions expressed are the sole responsibility of the DIRT editor and are in no sense the publication of the ABA.